I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
Local Council MP wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
Local Council MP wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
------------------------------------------
Not just 1 male playing in the Womens PL competition, 3 and counting.
How Is This Fair wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>Local Council MP wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>>I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
> ------------------------------------------
>Not just 1 male playing in the Womens PL competition, 3 and counting.
its not just men identifying as men, some of this teams players - at least 2 or 3 - actually look exactly like men. So its men playing against girls/women
Sam wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>Im involved in womens pl.
>its not just men identifying as men, some of this teams players - at least 2 or 3 - actually look exactly like men. So its men playing against girls/women
Suggest everyone tones down/completely stops this conversation. No doubt in this day and age any free speech against the rainbow warriors will see players, teams and clubs banned for life.
I fail to see how the mens comps are still called "mixed" and the womens are called "womens".
Aren't men allowed to have anything for themselves anymore?
Suggest everyone tones down/completely stops this conversation. No doubt in this day and age any free speech against the rainbow warriors will see players, teams and clubs banned for life.
I fail to see how the mens comps are still called "mixed" and the womens are called "womens".
Aren't men allowed to have anything for themselves anymore?
>>its not just men identifying as men, some of this teams players - at least 2 or 3 - actually look exactly like men. So its men playing against girls/women
> ------------------------------------------
>
>* typo - its not just men identifying as women
------------------------------------------
There's a few in all age that still look like men but they fit into the level they're playing at so it's fjne
The only way that this will get across the line is for the clubs to come together and draw a line in the sand and say we have a duty of care to our female members and will not play against Flying Bats FC.
Unfortunately the old days of people joining together in a just cause is a rare characteristic of someone character these days for fear of being ridiculed.
Time for Waud, Candy, Denyer, Tracey , Inglis, Pompeii and Nimmo to front up and make a stand.
According to the by laws all you need to do to play women's is say you're a woman. Don't need to prove you're one or show you're transitioning. You just need to say it...
Of course you are going to get this kind of response from people who want to live in a cave.
But in reality, Womens football is taking off, Peoples rights to identify as women is now spoken about.
So this whole discussion needs to be had.
Descrimination towards them will occur from time to time like racism still occurs from time to time, but as time goes on, so will peoples tollerence for this.
Of course wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>Of course you are going to get this kind of response from people who want to live in a cave.
>
>But in reality, Womens football is taking off, Peoples rights to identify as women is now spoken about.
>
>So this whole discussion needs to be had.
>
>Descrimination towards them will occur from time to time like racism still occurs from time to time, but as time goes on, so will peoples tollerence for this.
------------------------------------------
umm no.. you can't compare racism to a MAN wanting to be a woman.
It's extremely unfair for this team to be in the womens competition. Let me be clear, I have nothing against any gender or race going about their lives as they wish. But we have players who have the body shape and strength of men playing against women and in some cases young girls. Our club have 14 and 15 year old girls in our squad. We've played them twice, we were concerned for our teenager's safety playing against males that can potentially injure young girls.
If this team want to play football, fantastic. But it should be in the mixed comp.
>It's extremely unfair for this team to be in the womens competition. Let me be clear, I have nothing against any gender or race going about their lives as they wish. But we have players who have the body shape and strength of men playing against women and in some cases young girls. Our club have 14 and 15 year old girls in our squad. We've played them twice, we were concerned for our teenager's safety playing against males that can potentially injure young girls.
>If this team want to play football, fantastic. But it should be in the mixed comp.
------------------------------------------
I suggest if this is genuine you speak with your club delegate who
will take it up with the association.
your girls are playing in an open division which means they can play against 35-40 year olds potentially.
I also find this funny as I wasn't allowed to play a 15 year old goal keeper in PL reserve grade this season due to an "association rule preventing minors playing "...
>>It's extremely unfair for this team to be in the womens competition. Let me be clear, I have nothing against any gender or race going about their lives as they wish. But we have players who have the body shape and strength of men playing against women and in some cases young girls. Our club have 14 and 15 year old girls in our squad. We've played them twice, we were concerned for our teenager's safety playing against males that can potentially injure young girls.
>>If this team want to play football, fantastic. But it should be in the mixed comp.
> ------------------------------------------
>
>I suggest if this is genuine you speak with your club delegate who
>will take it up with the association.
>
>your girls are playing in an open division which means they can play against 35-40 year olds potentially.
>
>I also find this funny as I wasn't allowed to play a 15 year old goal keeper in PL reserve grade this season due to an "association rule preventing minors playing "...
>
>
>
>
>
------------------------------------------
Yeah they can potentially play against older WOMEN. No problem with that.
BTW, regarding your 15 yo GK, you do realise the Mens side of NWSF and the Womens side are two very different beasts. The Womens have their own rules and an "odd" way of doing some things
Good Riddance wrote: ------------------------------------------ >
>I see that the Flying Bats WPL with a number of transgender players are out of contention for the Grand Final.
>
>Good to see 3 clubs with players born as females will fight it out.
------------------------------------------
I saw the Bats this year and spoke with others that played them. Their transgender players did not stand out as footballers. The players from both teams in those games had an enjoyable, fair game as much as any other fixture. tbh the Bats attitude was friendly and positive. Their sideline was too, which is more than we can say for a few clubs. Anyway, seems hard to claim its an unfair advantage if they didnt even make the finals.
They're welcome in the comp in my view and maybe a few others can learn from their attitude to park footy.
The Bats did make the Championship finals series, just with 2 losses they can't make the Grand Final now.
They did finish in front of 4 teams and also beat the Premiers.
Irrespective that blokes playing in a female designated competition by way of gender identity is completely wrong.
As for players speaking up and saying what they believe it all comes down to be labelled as transphobic if that do.
Despite their attitude being friendly and positive on and off the field the real issue is allowing a person born as a male play against a person born as a female.
The tall, fast striker they have hits the ball better than a lot of males let alone females.
Forget this inclusion nonsense and just protect Womens football and all other sports as well.
>>I see that the Flying Bats WPL with a number of transgender players are out of contention for the Grand Final.
>>
>>Good to see 3 clubs with players born as females will fight it out.
> ------------------------------------------
>
>I saw the Bats this year and spoke with others that played them. Their transgender players did not stand out as footballers. The players from both teams in those games had an enjoyable, fair game as much as any other fixture. tbh the Bats attitude was friendly and positive. Their sideline was too, which is more than we can say for a few clubs. Anyway, seems hard to claim its an unfair advantage if they didnt even make the finals.
>They're welcome in the comp in my view and maybe a few others can learn from their attitude to park footy.
Local Council MP
wrote on 28-Jun-23 10:03I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
Cleanse Thy Self
wrote on 28-Jun-23 10:15Looks like you need to brush up on your bible work. The rainbow stays OUT of my Christian community.
Jed's Tits
wrote on 28-Jun-23 10:17Hills Association would never sign off on this
Surely NWSFA don't either, may as well have Hippopotamus round too
Adam Goodes
wrote on 28-Jun-23 10:33Why did they scrap the Indigenous round?
Uncter
wrote on 28-Jun-23 11:07The only rainbows at football should be the sour straps in the canteens
Not one
wrote on 28-Jun-23 14:37Local Council MP wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
------------------------------------------
Flying Bats have FOUR blokes playing Womens PL
THE ROCK
wrote on 28-Jun-23 17:19Who gives a shit about pride round.
let's just play football....
race, sexuality bla bla is something for off the field.
when you are on the field, everyone is fair game, everyone is equal.
I've played in many different associations and comps, players in Nwsf are usually respected by one another, and most people leave it on the field.
Some of the young pups don't understand this... but we have it prettt good.
Dr Dog
wrote on 28-Jun-23 19:55Fuck em, less is better
I fucking hate rainbows too
Gylfi Sigurdsson
wrote on 29-Jun-23 07:50Pride is for people like Gylfi
Leave it as it is
Emem Enefiok
wrote on 30-Jun-23 12:03Rainbows belong in the sky
Not in football
Emem Enefiok
wrote on 30-Jun-23 12:12Rainbows belong in the sky
Not in football
How Is This Fair
wrote on 01-Jul-23 09:43Local Council MP wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
------------------------------------------
Not just 1 male playing in the Womens PL competition, 3 and counting.
watts
wrote on 03-Jul-23 13:44>Flying Bats have FOUR blokes playing Womens PL
------------------------------------------
Is that the reason they're flying?
More
wrote on 03-Jul-23 15:44How Is This Fair wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Local Council MP wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>>I've only been to a few games this season, so I can't speak for all clubs here. I've noticed a lack of recognition of the rainbow community at games. The NPL women have gone as far as letting a man play for their team. What the fuck is this all about
>
------------------------------------------
>Not just 1 male playing in the Womens PL competition, 3 and counting.
>
------------------------------------------
Actually closer to 6
Anton
wrote on 03-Jul-23 16:23What's wrong with rainbows? We should be more inclusive of our gay counterparts
Anton 2
wrote on 04-Jul-23 09:02Shut the fuck up Anton
Herbert Chorley Cuthbert Babbage
wrote on 04-Jul-23 09:06I really like that muscly ref they call Joooze
Wonder what he would look like with only a rainbow armband on
Emem Enefiok
wrote on 04-Jul-23 09:07yes shut up anton, go to newtown league instead you KFC alphabet dude
flying bats should be shot out of the league
Archie The Dog
wrote on 04-Jul-23 17:25You all need to grow up.
Do your research. They identify as females. Let me play our wonderful game.
I can't wait for the female World Cup!
nobody reach for the chips too quickly!
Tiger Woods
wrote on 04-Jul-23 17:49Archie, they should stick to Golf. Heard that's a heaps gay sport to play especially on Mondays
Clear and present danger
wrote on 05-Jul-23 23:56Say what you will.
Men identifying as women, shouldn't be allowed to play in women's leagues.
it's not fair for the actual women(born women).
how will fifa handle it?
Sam
wrote on 06-Jul-23 19:40Im involved in womens pl.
its not just men identifying as men, some of this teams players - at least 2 or 3 - actually look exactly like men. So its men playing against girls/women
Sam
wrote on 06-Jul-23 19:41Sam wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Im involved in womens pl.
>its not just men identifying as men, some of this teams players - at least 2 or 3 - actually look exactly like men. So its men playing against girls/women
------------------------------------------
* typo - its not just men identifying as women
Woke crap
wrote on 06-Jul-23 20:35Suggest everyone tones down/completely stops this conversation. No doubt in this day and age any free speech against the rainbow warriors will see players, teams and clubs banned for life.
I fail to see how the mens comps are still called "mixed" and the womens are called "womens".
Aren't men allowed to have anything for themselves anymore?
Woke crap
wrote on 06-Jul-23 20:38Suggest everyone tones down/completely stops this conversation. No doubt in this day and age any free speech against the rainbow warriors will see players, teams and clubs banned for life.
I fail to see how the mens comps are still called "mixed" and the womens are called "womens".
Aren't men allowed to have anything for themselves anymore?
Kenthurst Keith
wrote on 07-Jul-23 08:43Lemme all tell ya, we blooded a Sheila this year into our ressies. Was a top notch bird, play the ball with both feet, not scared of a 50/50.
I dunno if she's gonna break into the first team, but sheZ beta than some of the blokes!
Men
wrote on 08-Jul-23 17:18Sam wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Sam wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>>Im involved in womens pl.
>>its not just men identifying as men, some of this teams players - at least 2 or 3 - actually look exactly like men. So its men playing against girls/women
>
------------------------------------------
>
>* typo - its not just men identifying as women
------------------------------------------
There's a few in all age that still look like men but they fit into the level they're playing at so it's fjne
Triviamaster
wrote on 08-Jul-23 18:51Rainbows belong nowhere in the world except Newtown
Emem Enefiok
wrote on 10-Jul-23 10:43#10 from St Pats would be a rainbow supporter
Little dwarf
Kenny Ryan
wrote on 14-Jul-23 08:0610 from Pats is confirmed Oxford Street hanger outer
Serious
wrote on 14-Jul-23 12:16I know of at least three club presidents who are considering forfeiting each game against flying bats next season in womens pl
T1m Bailey
wrote on 14-Jul-23 12:36Come on fellas - there surely ok for mediocre males to wanna win something/silverware with the ladies. get with the program.
FIFA-Endorsed
Solidarity Forever
wrote on 14-Jul-23 19:23The only way that this will get across the line is for the clubs to come together and draw a line in the sand and say we have a duty of care to our female members and will not play against Flying Bats FC.
Unfortunately the old days of people joining together in a just cause is a rare characteristic of someone character these days for fear of being ridiculed.
Time for Waud, Candy, Denyer, Tracey , Inglis, Pompeii and Nimmo to front up and make a stand.
Serious wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>I know of at least three club presidents who are considering forfeiting each game against flying bats next season in womens pl
------------------------------------------
By laws
wrote on 14-Jul-23 22:27According to the by laws all you need to do to play women's is say you're a woman. Don't need to prove you're one or show you're transitioning. You just need to say it...
THE ROCK
wrote on 15-Jul-23 07:02Unbelievable....
I am truely shocked how this has been allowed to happen.
not a hater by any mean, but fairs fair as much as women want equality etc, you can't have men playing against women esp if they are hurting them.
This is beyond my pay grade, but it needs to be addressed in a logical and tasteful way.
Hasn't this been sorted at a higher level?
Woke
wrote on 15-Jul-23 17:26Welcome to the world of WOKE this whole country is stuffed.
Linked all the way in
wrote on 16-Jul-23 19:27Bunch of fucking fags, fuck them all
Of course
wrote on 19-Jul-23 12:12Of course you are going to get this kind of response from people who want to live in a cave.
But in reality, Womens football is taking off, Peoples rights to identify as women is now spoken about.
So this whole discussion needs to be had.
Descrimination towards them will occur from time to time like racism still occurs from time to time, but as time goes on, so will peoples tollerence for this.
.
wrote on 19-Jul-23 17:00Of course wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Of course you are going to get this kind of response from people who want to live in a cave.
>
>But in reality, Womens football is taking off, Peoples rights to identify as women is now spoken about.
>
>So this whole discussion needs to be had.
>
>Descrimination towards them will occur from time to time like racism still occurs from time to time, but as time goes on, so will peoples tollerence for this.
------------------------------------------
umm no.. you can't compare racism to a MAN wanting to be a woman.
Check This Out
wrote on 19-Jul-23 18:46https://reduxx.info/exclusive-trans-identified-male-seen-injuring-female-player-during-womens-league-game/
Jon Jones
wrote on 19-Jul-23 22:27Seriously, if you support it you need ya head kicked in
Amen
wrote on 20-Jul-23 23:38Jon Jones wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Seriously, if you support it you need ya head kicked in
------------------------------------------
amen
McCabe
wrote on 22-Jul-23 09:54Trans aside
There seem to be more lesbians in W0mens Fo0tball than gays in Mens' Football. generally any where.
we need mre gay men in GHFA
Bunch of flogs
wrote on 22-Jul-23 18:36You are all a bunch of absolute cavemen with ur opinions. Embarrassing for the competition. Shameful
Ginger garden gnome
wrote on 22-Jul-23 21:47McCabe wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Trans aside
>There seem to be more lesbians in W0mens Fo0tball than gays in Mens' Football. generally any where.
>
>we need mre gay men in GHFA
------------------------------------------
they got relegated last week.
bye Ryde saints
Harden Up
wrote on 22-Jul-23 23:04Bunch of flogs wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>You are all a bunch of absolute cavemen with ur opinions. Embarrassing for the competition. Shameful
------------------------------------------
Your g-banger must be riding up, harden up princess
Dragons mum
wrote on 23-Jul-23 18:09It's extremely unfair for this team to be in the womens competition.
Let me be clear, I have nothing against any gender or race going about their lives as they wish.
But we have players who have the body shape and strength of men playing against women and in some cases young girls. Our club have 14 and 15 year old girls in our squad. We've played them twice, we were concerned for our teenager's safety playing against males that can potentially injure young girls.
If this team want to play football, fantastic. But it should be in the mixed comp.
THE ROCK
wrote on 23-Jul-23 19:45Dragons mum wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>It's extremely unfair for this team to be in the womens competition.
Let me be clear, I have nothing against any gender or race going about their lives as they wish.
But we have players who have the body shape and strength of men playing against women and in some cases young girls. Our club have 14 and 15 year old girls in our squad. We've played them twice, we were concerned for our teenager's safety playing against males that can potentially injure young girls.
>If this team want to play football, fantastic. But it should be in the mixed comp.
------------------------------------------
I suggest if this is genuine you speak with your club delegate who
will take it up with the association.
your girls are playing in an open division which means they can play against 35-40 year olds potentially.
I also find this funny as I wasn't allowed to play a 15 year old goal keeper in PL reserve grade this season due to an "association rule preventing minors playing "...
Its me
wrote on 23-Jul-23 21:02THE ROCK wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Dragons mum wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>>It's extremely unfair for this team to be in the womens competition.
Let me be clear, I have nothing against any gender or race going about their lives as they wish.
But we have players who have the body shape and strength of men playing against women and in some cases young girls. Our club have 14 and 15 year old girls in our squad. We've played them twice, we were concerned for our teenager's safety playing against males that can potentially injure young girls.
>>If this team want to play football, fantastic. But it should be in the mixed comp.
>
------------------------------------------
>
>I suggest if this is genuine you speak with your club delegate who
>will take it up with the association.
>
>your girls are playing in an open division which means they can play against 35-40 year olds potentially.
>
>I also find this funny as I wasn't allowed to play a 15 year old goal keeper in PL reserve grade this season due to an "association rule preventing minors playing "...
>
>
>
>
>
------------------------------------------
Yeah they can potentially play against older WOMEN. No problem with that.
BTW, regarding your 15 yo GK, you do realise the Mens side of NWSF and the Womens side are two very different beasts. The Womens have their own rules and an "odd" way of doing some things
Good Riddance
wrote on 15-Aug-23 20:15I see that the Flying Bats WPL with a number of transgender players are out of contention for the Grand Final.
Good to see 3 clubs with players born as females will fight it out.
Welcome
wrote on 16-Aug-23 14:08Good Riddance wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>I see that the Flying Bats WPL with a number of transgender players are out of contention for the Grand Final.
>
>Good to see 3 clubs with players born as females will fight it out.
------------------------------------------
I saw the Bats this year and spoke with others that played them. Their transgender players did not stand out as footballers. The players from both teams in those games had an enjoyable, fair game as much as any other fixture. tbh the Bats attitude was friendly and positive. Their sideline was too, which is more than we can say for a few clubs. Anyway, seems hard to claim its an unfair advantage if they didnt even make the finals.
They're welcome in the comp in my view and maybe a few others can learn from their attitude to park footy.
Good Riddance
wrote on 16-Aug-23 14:26The Bats did make the Championship finals series, just with 2 losses they can't make the Grand Final now.
They did finish in front of 4 teams and also beat the Premiers.
Irrespective that blokes playing in a female designated competition by way of gender identity is completely wrong.
As for players speaking up and saying what they believe it all comes down to be labelled as transphobic if that do.
Despite their attitude being friendly and positive on and off the field the real issue is allowing a person born as a male play against a person born as a female.
The tall, fast striker they have hits the ball better than a lot of males let alone females.
Forget this inclusion nonsense and just protect Womens football and all other sports as well.
They can play but play as they were born.
Chopper
wrote on 16-Aug-23 22:11Welcome wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>Good Riddance wrote:
------------------------------------------
>
>>I see that the Flying Bats WPL with a number of transgender players are out of contention for the Grand Final.
>>
>>Good to see 3 clubs with players born as females will fight it out.
>
------------------------------------------
>
>I saw the Bats this year and spoke with others that played them. Their transgender players did not stand out as footballers. The players from both teams in those games had an enjoyable, fair game as much as any other fixture. tbh the Bats attitude was friendly and positive. Their sideline was too, which is more than we can say for a few clubs. Anyway, seems hard to claim its an unfair advantage if they didnt even make the finals.
>They're welcome in the comp in my view and maybe a few others can learn from their attitude to park footy.
------------------------------------------
Harden the f*ck up princess