You are incorrect on so many levels.
And obviously from Putney.
There are 3 clubs i know of who want to come up. One of those has a particularly strong chance.
In previous seasons teams that have finished last the season before have stayed in SL as no other club wanted to come up. Next season will be a different story.
The by-law clearly states "the team that finishes last in Super League to be relegated".
A couple of big wins against depleted crap teams at the end of the season means nothing and doesn't mask their utterly crap season.
Dream on and enjoy AA
im actually from a team in the pl
teams that are meant to get relegated can renominate and even though you may know of people who are saying they want to come in they will still have to compete against putney
and also the teams they played may have been depleted but does that really matter
it shows the ghfa that they had a good squad right till the very end of a season which is what new teams that come up fail to do
Dude, your clearly from PL but i appreciate your ambition.
Reality is..... YES you can nominate.
However, any team (and this isnt open to interpretation. it is fact) that nominates is automatically ahead of you, regardless of which division they were in previously, etc.
The reality is you will probably go down, however will probably be back after 1 year. Use it as a chanc eto clean out the team and build stronger.
sorry Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> sorry meant SL
I propose a new system.....
I propose we reverse the cycle of relegation. Ie any team that gets relegated from Premier League goes to AA, and any team relegated from AA goes to Super League and so on....
This should technically solve all of our problems, and allow us to progress as successive grassfootballers
Fred Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> You are incorrect on so many levels.
> And obviously from Putney.
>
> There are 3 clubs i know of who want to come up.
> One of those has a particularly strong chance.
> In previous seasons teams that have finished last
> the season before have stayed in SL as no other
> club wanted to come up. Next season will be a
> different story.
>
> The by-law clearly states "the team that finishes
> last in Super League to be relegated".
>
> A couple of big wins against depleted crap teams
> at the end of the season means nothing and doesn't
> mask their utterly crap season.
>
> Dream on and enjoy AA
Since when do the GHFA actually follow their own by-laws??? They make it up as they go along and when the Putney president is also on the GHFA board.......
Prems Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> How about we just premier league
Mate no need to 'f$&k' premier league... With my exclusive new system, super league will become premier league and premier league will become super league
Defector Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> No one thinks that another club wont defect to the
> Hills comp that have a PL or SL team next season?
> That might help Putney stay up.
Why would anyone want to play in th hill Billie Comp?
Whats the fuss Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> What actually is the issue with thunder?
I'd like to know aswell, im from rangers and i thought there was worst then thunder. Redbacks ressies were up there.
SL Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Whats the fuss Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > What actually is the issue with thunder?
>
>
> I'd like to know aswell, im from rangers and i
> thought there was worst then thunder. Redbacks
> ressies were up there.
They are pretty good this year
Northern HFC and Saints were usually good for a threat to your life or a potential fight
If any team outside of the current PL/SL setup nominates, they will get in ahead of Putney.
If not, Putney will be back in.
I'm not posting this up to create endless back and forth, or have a dig, just the rules as they are interpreted at board level.
"The club that comes last in SL is relegated" I've been in the meetings where this is discussed, and it basically means that if say North Ryde, or Old Ignatians or anyone else nominates... their nominated takes precedence over Putney.
I also understand the Putney winning AA1 argument, however the "relegation" is at club level, not team level. This is to protect AA1 becoming a Super League insurance policy, will all the bottom clubs in SL also putting teams in AA1 to 'protect' themselves.
I think the Putney boys are a good bunch of lads and can definitely play on their day, however they are almost certainly out for 2018, but I would expect them back again in 19.
Happy to answer any questions any one has, but as stated above, this isnt designed to create animosity or have a dig.... just how the rules will be applied.
newbs
wrote on 11-Aug-17 08:08anyone that thinks putney is going down to all age next season obviously havnt played in the ghfa for very long
teams notoriously dont want to move into sl from all age, even if they have the players and the quality
putney is already established as a sl squad and have 2 aa1 teams and multiple other all age teams to draw players from
putney also proved that they do have the heart to be in the league by putting those big wins on at the end of the season when other teams had given up
the ghfa likes to give teams second chances and only resorts to bringing teams up when they have to
Fred
wrote on 11-Aug-17 10:00You are incorrect on so many levels. And obviously from Putney. There are 3 clubs i know of who want to come up. One of those has a particularly strong chance. In previous seasons teams that have finished last the season before have stayed in SL as no other club wanted to come up. Next season will be a different story. The by-law clearly states "the team that finishes last in Super League to be relegated". A couple of big wins against depleted crap teams at the end of the season means nothing and doesn't mask their utterly crap season. Dream on and enjoy AA
newbs
wrote on 11-Aug-17 11:00im actually from a team in the pl teams that are meant to get relegated can renominate and even though you may know of people who are saying they want to come in they will still have to compete against putney and also the teams they played may have been depleted but does that really matter it shows the ghfa that they had a good squad right till the very end of a season which is what new teams that come up fail to do
Gregor
wrote on 11-Aug-17 11:04From PL. worried about SL. Ok mate
sorry
wrote on 11-Aug-17 13:05sorry meant SL
dood
wrote on 11-Aug-17 13:05Dude, your clearly from PL but i appreciate your ambition. Reality is..... YES you can nominate. However, any team (and this isnt open to interpretation. it is fact) that nominates is automatically ahead of you, regardless of which division they were in previously, etc. The reality is you will probably go down, however will probably be back after 1 year. Use it as a chanc eto clean out the team and build stronger.
The Fixer
wrote on 11-Aug-17 16:04sorry Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > sorry meant SL I propose a new system..... I propose we reverse the cycle of relegation. Ie any team that gets relegated from Premier League goes to AA, and any team relegated from AA goes to Super League and so on.... This should technically solve all of our problems, and allow us to progress as successive grassfootballers
What
wrote on 11-Aug-17 16:09What are you talking about? Bit early to be hitting the booze mate
Prems
wrote on 11-Aug-17 17:03How about we just premier league.
Fred 2
wrote on 11-Aug-17 17:07Fred Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > You are incorrect on so many levels. > And obviously from Putney. > > There are 3 clubs i know of who want to come up. > One of those has a particularly strong chance. > In previous seasons teams that have finished last > the season before have stayed in SL as no other > club wanted to come up. Next season will be a > different story. > > The by-law clearly states "the team that finishes > last in Super League to be relegated". > > A couple of big wins against depleted crap teams > at the end of the season means nothing and doesn't > mask their utterly crap season. > > Dream on and enjoy AA Since when do the GHFA actually follow their own by-laws??? They make it up as they go along and when the Putney president is also on the GHFA board.......
The Fixer
wrote on 12-Aug-17 13:09Prems Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > How about we just premier league Mate no need to 'f$&k' premier league... With my exclusive new system, super league will become premier league and premier league will become super league
Defector
wrote on 12-Aug-17 23:00No one thinks that another club wont defect to the Hills comp that have a PL or SL team next season? That might help Putney stay up.
Hmm
wrote on 15-Aug-17 02:00Defector Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > No one thinks that another club wont defect to the > Hills comp that have a PL or SL team next season? > That might help Putney stay up. Why would anyone want to play in th hill Billie Comp?
Perfect match
wrote on 15-Aug-17 10:06Sounds perfect for the Thornleigh bunch..
Whats the fuss
wrote on 15-Aug-17 14:00What actually is the issue with thunder?
H8ters
wrote on 15-Aug-17 14:06To be fair they didn't try to fight anyone, threaten to kill you or try to fight you in the car park after the game like other teams we played...
Can't handle the heat ?
wrote on 15-Aug-17 17:02You thunder lot sure can dish out plenty but don't like when the truth is told.. thunderstruck perhaps ?
SL
wrote on 15-Aug-17 18:05Whats the fuss Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > What actually is the issue with thunder? I'd like to know aswell, im from rangers and i thought there was worst then thunder. Redbacks ressies were up there.
Smack down vs Raw
wrote on 15-Aug-17 20:07SL Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Whats the fuss Wrote: > -------------------------------------------------- > ----- > > What actually is the issue with thunder? > > > I'd like to know aswell, im from rangers and i > thought there was worst then thunder. Redbacks > ressies were up there. They are pretty good this year Northern HFC and Saints were usually good for a threat to your life or a potential fight
Silent Knight
wrote on 27-Sep-17 22:08Anyone know what's happening yet?
yes
wrote on 09-Oct-17 13:09If any team outside of the current PL/SL setup nominates, they will get in ahead of Putney. If not, Putney will be back in. I'm not posting this up to create endless back and forth, or have a dig, just the rules as they are interpreted at board level. "The club that comes last in SL is relegated" I've been in the meetings where this is discussed, and it basically means that if say North Ryde, or Old Ignatians or anyone else nominates... their nominated takes precedence over Putney. I also understand the Putney winning AA1 argument, however the "relegation" is at club level, not team level. This is to protect AA1 becoming a Super League insurance policy, will all the bottom clubs in SL also putting teams in AA1 to 'protect' themselves. I think the Putney boys are a good bunch of lads and can definitely play on their day, however they are almost certainly out for 2018, but I would expect them back again in 19. Happy to answer any questions any one has, but as stated above, this isnt designed to create animosity or have a dig.... just how the rules will be applied.
wondring
wrote on 11-Oct-17 16:08what happens if we lose hills hawks will putney still be the lat option with 2 teams coming up?
Yes
wrote on 12-Oct-17 21:07Yes
wrong
wrote on 05-Dec-17 07:05love it Putney are staying up all you smart ass keyboard warriors were wrong I'm so happy right now 'but but but the by laws' hahahahahah suck it up
yes!
wrote on 06-Dec-17 10:06We all want Putney in... 6 point's all round Its like an Oprah giveaway You get 6 points You get 6 points Everybody gets 6 points!
Me123
wrote on 06-Dec-17 10:09You might be happy, but not as happy as us. Your club are useless so easy wins all round!
Wrong
wrote on 06-Dec-17 11:07Hahahahaha by law blah blah Putney are in. Hopefully they clear out some shit players and get a new coach or else it will be a repeat season.
Coach 1
wrote on 06-Dec-17 15:06Anyone know the new WRR coach where did he come from?
yeah baby!
wrote on 06-Dec-17 17:05Thats great, Putney is back in couple of easy wins to prop up the points tally