GHFA Premier League
Sponsors of the
Golden Boot &
Tipping Competition
Sponsors of the
Best Defence Award
Co-sponsor of the
Tipping Competition
Co-sponsor of the
Golden Boot
Pages: 12Next
Current Page: 1 of 2
How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Football Genius ()
Date: December 08, 2020 02:43PM

Can someone tell me how NER were not deducted points for an illegal player and why forfeits weren't applied for the games he played?

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: News ()
Date: December 08, 2020 03:56PM

Did you receive some news that you would like to share with the rest of the forum?

Or should we just assume from this that EFC's complaint was rejected and they are getting relegated

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: TG ()
Date: December 08, 2020 04:15PM

Look all NPL cOntracts were null and void this year cause of corona so players had the option of playing for no money or little he chose not to travel to manly 3 times a week and play for $50 instead he played with his junior club.Because he had no contract he was not registered with manly.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Inside man ()
Date: December 08, 2020 06:09PM

PL and SL competitions confirmed.
North epping in PL
2 x Epping FC in SL

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Truth? ()
Date: December 08, 2020 06:22PM

Inside man Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> PL and SL competitions confirmed.
> North epping in PL
> 2 x Epping FC in SL


Is this actually true? Far out we have had flipping 10 verdicts. Can someone actually confirm this from either club?

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Locked in ()
Date: December 08, 2020 06:57PM

PL: Eastwood St Andrews, Epping Eastwood, Hills Hawks, Macquarie Dragons, Normanhurst, North Epping Rangers, Pennant Hills, Ryde Saints United, West Ryde Rovers & WPH Cherrybrook

SL: Epping FC (Blue), Epping FC (Red), Gladesville Ravens, North Ryde, Northern HFC, Putney Rangers, Redbacks, Roselea, St Patricks & Thornleigh

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Toovey ()
Date: December 09, 2020 09:53AM

Good to see 2 new teams in S/L roselea,north Ryde.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: 10 Team ()
Date: December 09, 2020 10:43AM

Great to see SL back to being a 10 team competition

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Technically Speaking ()
Date: December 09, 2020 02:23PM

Locked in Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> PL: Eastwood St Andrews, Epping Eastwood, Hills
> Hawks, Macquarie Dragons, Normanhurst, North
> Epping Rangers, Pennant Hills, Ryde Saints United,
> West Ryde Rovers & WPH Cherrybrook
>
> SL: Epping FC (Blue), Epping FC (Red), Gladesville
> Ravens, North Ryde, Northern HFC, Putney Rangers,
> Redbacks, Roselea, St Patricks & Thornleigh


Didn’t Epping FC’s SL 1st grade team finished last in 1st grade and also in PL;
by logic, their PL side is relegated to SL and their SL side relegated to AAM1’s?

Can’t hack the saltiness that both PL&SL squads got relegated?!

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Election Fraud ()
Date: December 09, 2020 02:44PM

Technically Speaking Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Locked in Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > PL: Eastwood St Andrews, Epping Eastwood, Hills
> > Hawks, Macquarie Dragons, Normanhurst, North
> > Epping Rangers, Pennant Hills, Ryde Saints
> United,
> > West Ryde Rovers & WPH Cherrybrook
> >
> > SL: Epping FC (Blue), Epping FC (Red),
> Gladesville
> > Ravens, North Ryde, Northern HFC, Putney
> Rangers,
> > Redbacks, Roselea, St Patricks & Thornleigh
>
>
> Didn’t Epping FC’s SL 1st grade team finished
> last in 1st grade and also in PL;
> by logic, their PL side is relegated to SL and
> their SL side relegated to AAM1’s?
>
> Can’t hack the saltiness that both PL&SL squads
> got relegated?!

obviously no-one else nominated for SL.

Cant see why you would want to run 2 squads in the same comp though, would be better to consolidate them both for potentially 1 decent squad seeing as both 1st grade teams have finished bottom 2 or 3 the last 2 seasons.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Epping is cool ()
Date: December 10, 2020 07:16AM

We sent a letter to look into the unregistered player

They replied and said yes unregistered but it was a mistake.....UNREAL

Why have the rule book????

Have fun in PL

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Donald Trump ()
Date: December 10, 2020 07:23AM

Would you really expect them to invalidate a season of hard work for a squad of 35 players over the mistake of another club? (Assuming what was said previously about manly being the ones that made the mistake is true)

Theres no indication anywhere on this forum that north epping knowingly did anything wrong so why not give them the benefit of the doubt?

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Uncool you ()
Date: December 10, 2020 07:42AM

Would it help Stan if I told you that the president of our association is the resgistra of North Epping.
Seems that they don’t want your club there mate.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Epping is cool ()
Date: December 10, 2020 08:54AM

Mistake or not its against the rules...

Oh sorry I didnt realise, it was a mistake opens the door now for more mistakes...

We came last so I need to suck it up..Feel like im getting a bag of dogshit for Xmas this year.....

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Rudi ()
Date: December 10, 2020 10:02AM

Icompman system should be built where it prevents this. One Club shouldn't be chasing another club - hey is he de registered and they say um oh yeah he is when he isn't.

If EEW or WPH had done the same would St Andrews demand they play a new Grand Final?

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Registered ()
Date: December 10, 2020 10:02AM

He was registered the entire season, it was an issue of deregistration from Manly which is nothing to do with NER

You saying "he was unregistered" is completely untrue

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: TG ()
Date: December 10, 2020 10:27AM

He didn’t have a contract at manly so he wasn’t registered at manly end of story.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Epping is cool ()
Date: December 10, 2020 10:37AM

first 3 games he was registered with Manly

Their mistake and Epping pay for it....!!!

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Get over it ()
Date: December 10, 2020 11:39AM

Keep crying Epping! You guys sucked all year so trying to remain in a league that is obviously far above your skill level on a technicality just sounds desperate. Delaying the inevitable, if you were to magically stay up you’d barely last the next season before being tossed back down to SL where, let’s be perfectly frank, your squad needs to be.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Mark Clattenberg ()
Date: December 10, 2020 12:26PM

Toovey Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Good to see 2 new teams in S/L roselea,north Ryde.

Indeed Toovs. Makes a much better competition all round. Hopefully both teams don't bomb or become easy beats.

Roselea's AA/1 side this year were the old Mac Uni SL/PL side so their First Grade side will mainly consist of those boys and then their ressies will contain potentially some players from AA/4, AA/6 and maybe AA/8 (respectably came 6th, 7th and 1st). I say that because it would seem highly unlikely that Roselea would play players from their 21/3's side from this year and they don't have an 18's, 16's or even 15's side. Probably hoping that some randoms from different AA and SL sides come out and try.

North Ryde is quite an intriguing addition. Mark Simpson really wanted a North Ryde side in SL but I don't see where they would get decent players from.
North Ryde's highest AA team last season was a team in AA8 and AA9 (who respectably came 7th and 3rd). Their 21/1's team that made the semi's and final two years in a row, disbanded this season because of severe divisions within players and half of them moved to AA and the other half to the Macquarie Dragons 21/1's side that won the comp this year.
Unless Mark can re-group the AA/3 side in 2019 as well as the 21/1's side to form a SL side then I'm not convinced a bunch of AA/8-9 players can make the cut (happy to eat some humble pie if they out-perform).

If there are any Ryde Saints lads on here, I was hearing from the Saints 18/1's coach that won the comp this year that they wanted to combine the two 18 sides to make a Super League team like Epping. I'm guessing that fell through then?

Really glad though it's back to 10 teams.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Poached ()
Date: December 10, 2020 12:49PM

Mark Clattenberg Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Toovey Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > Good to see 2 new teams in S/L roselea,north
> Ryde.
>
> Indeed Toovs. Makes a much better competition all
> round. Hopefully both teams don't bomb or become
> easy beats.
>
> Roselea's AA/1 side this year were the old Mac Uni
> SL/PL side so their First Grade side will mainly
> consist of those boys and then their ressies will
> contain potentially some players from AA/4, AA/6
> and maybe AA/8 (respectably came 6th, 7th and
> 1st). I say that because it would seem highly
> unlikely that Roselea would play players from
> their 21/3's side from this year and they don't
> have an 18's, 16's or even 15's side. Probably
> hoping that some randoms from different AA and SL
> sides come out and try.
>
> North Ryde is quite an intriguing addition. Mark
> Simpson really wanted a North Ryde side in SL but
> I don't see where they would get decent players
> from.
> North Ryde's highest AA team last season was a
> team in AA8 and AA9 (who respectably came 7th and
> 3rd). Their 21/1's team that made the semi's and
> final two years in a row, disbanded this season
> because of severe divisions within players and
> half of them moved to AA and the other half to the
> Macquarie Dragons 21/1's side that won the comp
> this year.
> Unless Mark can re-group the AA/3 side in 2019 as
> well as the 21/1's side to form a SL side then I'm
> not convinced a bunch of AA/8-9 players can make
> the cut (happy to eat some humble pie if they
> out-perform).
>
> If there are any Ryde Saints lads on here, I was
> hearing from the Saints 18/1's coach that won the
> comp this year that they wanted to combine the two
> 18 sides to make a Super League team like Epping.
> I'm guessing that fell through then?
>
> Really glad though it's back to 10 teams.


Good luck Roselea if that’s the case.
The 2019 Mac uni squad was a joke and what few good players they had got nabbed by other clubs for the season just gone.

Heard from a mate at North ryde they were counting on something to happen football wise which may not happen now so I don’t know where their 35 odd players are going to come from

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Joke ()
Date: December 11, 2020 07:14AM

Poached Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Mark Clattenberg Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > Toovey Wrote:
> >
> --------------------------------------------------
>
> > -----
> > > Good to see 2 new teams in S/L roselea,north
> > Ryde.
> >
> > Indeed Toovs. Makes a much better competition
> all
> > round. Hopefully both teams don't bomb or
> become
> > easy beats.
> >
> > Roselea's AA/1 side this year were the old Mac
> Uni
> > SL/PL side so their First Grade side will
> mainly
> > consist of those boys and then their ressies
> will
> > contain potentially some players from AA/4,
> AA/6
> > and maybe AA/8 (respectably came 6th, 7th and
> > 1st). I say that because it would seem highly
> > unlikely that Roselea would play players from
> > their 21/3's side from this year and they don't
> > have an 18's, 16's or even 15's side. Probably
> > hoping that some randoms from different AA and
> SL
> > sides come out and try.
> >
> > North Ryde is quite an intriguing addition.
> Mark
> > Simpson really wanted a North Ryde side in SL
> but
> > I don't see where they would get decent players
> > from.
> > North Ryde's highest AA team last season was a
> > team in AA8 and AA9 (who respectably came 7th
> and
> > 3rd). Their 21/1's team that made the semi's
> and
> > final two years in a row, disbanded this season
> > because of severe divisions within players and
> > half of them moved to AA and the other half to
> the
> > Macquarie Dragons 21/1's side that won the comp
> > this year.
> > Unless Mark can re-group the AA/3 side in 2019
> as
> > well as the 21/1's side to form a SL side then
> I'm
> > not convinced a bunch of AA/8-9 players can
> make
> > the cut (happy to eat some humble pie if they
> > out-perform).
> >
> > If there are any Ryde Saints lads on here, I
> was
> > hearing from the Saints 18/1's coach that won
> the
> > comp this year that they wanted to combine the
> two
> > 18 sides to make a Super League team like
> Epping.
> > I'm guessing that fell through then?
> >
> > Really glad though it's back to 10 teams.
>
>
> Good luck Roselea if that’s the case.
> The 2019 Mac uni squad was a joke and what few
> good players they had got nabbed by other clubs
> for the season just gone.
>
> Heard from a mate at North ryde they were counting
> on something to happen football wise which may not
> happen now so I don’t know where their 35 odd
> players are going to come from

Doesn't North Ryde always apply to become part of Super League every year? I remember 2018 they tried to and were confirmed and then had to pull out due to not having enough players to make a squad.

Something that Mark Clattenberg didn't mention is that North Ryde had a Under 18 Division One side that came 6th I think. Not very convincing at all...

Rosalea are going to be a joke. End of story. Mac Uni were rubbish when they last played and they will be a joke again. Couldn't even muster themselves into the Top 4. What a joke.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Pet barn ()
Date: December 11, 2020 11:59AM

You had a bag of dog shit this year in your squad.That’s why you ran last it all starts at the top mate you turn up to training in thongs and Hawaiian shirt that what you get.So get off jacks case and start rebuilding.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Bielsa Spygate ()
Date: December 11, 2020 12:59PM

Pet barn Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> You had a bag of dog shit this year in your
> squad.That’s why you ran last it all starts at
> the top mate you turn up to training in thongs and
> Hawaiian shirt that what you get.So get off jacks
> case and start rebuilding.

It's more than that. No only are there lads in that team that aren't good enough to be playing Premier League, the deadweights of the side such as Cam Jones, Rubeun and Ryan began to defy orders from Stan on the training grounds. Stan would say one thing, Ruben and co. would say another.

They really need to grow a pair and kick out the disease before it infects the club as a whole...

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Epping is cool ()
Date: December 11, 2020 01:47PM

Wow boys....salty
I’m not having a go at jack

People pay money to play in an organised comp
With rules and a constitution
Need to follow the rules or it’s shit show....

This or similar could happen to another club so rules make it consistent

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: TG ()
Date: December 11, 2020 02:26PM

Happy to swap places with you next year mate.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: FBI ()
Date: December 11, 2020 03:08PM

Epping is cool Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Wow boys....salty
> I’m not having a go at jack
>
> People pay money to play in an organised comp
> With rules and a constitution
> Need to follow the rules or it’s shit show....
>
> This or similar could happen to another club so
> rules make it consistent


I agree 100%, rules and regulations are in place to apply equally to all.

I can only find Jack Fulton playing for Manly on the 7/3 and 14/3 this season.

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Really ()
Date: December 11, 2020 03:22PM

TG Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Happy to swap places with you next year mate.


TG are you offering for Normo to drop down to superleague or are you in the hunt for a new club?

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: Epping is cool ()
Date: December 11, 2020 03:40PM

Merry Xmas guys

And good luck to all teams next year.....enjoy

Options: ReplyQuote
Re: How is NER still in PL after playing illegal player all year
Posted by: TG ()
Date: December 11, 2020 03:42PM

None of the above.

Options: ReplyQuote
Pages: 12Next
Current Page: 1 of 2


Your Name: 
Your Email: 
Subject: 
Spam prevention:
Please, solve the mathematical question and enter the answer in the input field below. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
Question: how much is 5 plus 6?